Biden admin asks SCOTUS to uphold Obamacare, reversing Trump support for lawsuit

The Biden administration is withdrawing the federal government’s support for a challenge to Obamacare, telling the Supreme Court that the law should remain on the books.

The move by the Justice Department follows speculation on whether Biden would try to withdraw from the high-profile red state lawsuit — fully supported by the Trump administration — to strike down the entirety of the Affordable Care Act.

“Following the change in Administration, the Department of Justice has reconsidered the government’s position in these cases,” Deputy Solicitor General Edwin Kneedler wrote to the court on Wednesday. The U.S. government, he wrote, “no longer adheres to the conclusions in the previously filed brief of the federal respondents.”

The move will likely have little impact on the outcome of the case, which the justices heard one week after Election Day and could decide on soon. But the new filing signals the Biden administration’s support for a health care law he campaigned on bolstering and that Congress is now working to expand.

Background: The Trump administration powered a longshot lawsuit from a red state coalition seeking to overturn Obamacare. The states, led by Texas, argued that the law was no longer constitutional after the GOP-led Congress in 2017 effectively axed the ACA’s tax penalty for not buying insurance. Many legal experts believed the challenge to health care law was thin, but Republican-appointed justices in lower courts sided with the red states.

A majority of Supreme Court justices during Nov. 10 oral arguments seemed inclined to preserve much of the law. During those arguments, a DOJ lawyer contended that the law’s insurance protections and other sweeping reforms are unconstitutional without any forceful mandate to compel people into the insurance markets.

The new DOJ letter said even if the Supreme Court finds that the law’s individual mandate is no longer constitutional, it can be easily separated from the rest of the law. However, the new administration isn’t asking to file any more briefings, given that arguments were held months ago.

What’s next: The justices are expected to rule on the law’s constitutionality in the coming weeks or months.


About the author


Leave a Comment